I love barbecue! And I love all the opinions that barbecue stirs up. I never imagined that my Monster Potato post would elicit so many comments.
First, a little barbecue background. I grew up in North Carolina so the mighty pig (specifically a vinegar-doused pulled pork sandwich topped with vinegary green slaw) is my emotional touch point. If someone dares to serve me a “North Carolina” barbecue sandwich made with purple cabbage and mayo on a sesame-seed bun, I’m apoplectic!
That said, when barbecue became my life’s pursuit, I traveled all over and became an equal opportunity barbecuer. I truly believe that all the authentic styles/regions should be critiqued in their own region—99.9% of the time, people prefer and fight for the barbecue they grew up on. If I had to choose between a pulled pork sandwich from Wayne Monk’s restaurant in Lexington, NC, or anything else, I’d choose Monk’s sandwich! Once you embrace all the barbecue styles and cultures, your life only gets richer (and maybe your waist gets a little thicker!).
It’s "old hat" to some, but topping a baked potato with chopped smoked meat and barbecue sauce was news to me—and I see from the comments that there are fans from all over. As far as being “real” barbecue…the potato is topped with real barbecued meat, smoked over post oak low and slow. And, obviously, top your potato with as much or as little as you like—my recipe is only a point of departure!
For the past four years, I have been involved with a barbecue restaurant share group that includes the top restaurants/joints/dives in the country. Believe it or not, there are all kinds of other non-traditional dishes on most barbecue menus that utilize the smoked meat. Some of the most popular are Barbecue Pie, Barbecue Pizza, Barbecue Nachos, Barbecue Chili, etc. Guess why? These pitmasters and restaurant owners are trying to make a buck and an item that can get people talking (like the potato) brings cash and folks into the restaurant. I expect that you will find a Monster Potato on my menu at Hill Country sometime soon!
Restaurateurs don’t necessarily want you to eat the whole thing; they are giving us what we’ve asked for. Americans don’t like restaurants that serve small portions. Whether they eat it all or should eat it all is another matter; consumers vote with their dollars and like it or not, American consumers love and buy big portions. As far as cooking the potato, I agree wholeheartedly! My mother taught me to prep a “baked potato” by rubbing it with a little Crisco and pricking it a few times with a fork. I’ve never done it any other way for russet and/or sweet potatoes. I’d never use foil myself, but most restaurants do it for sanitary reasons.
No matter how you cook it, how you see it, or how you feel about it, the plain truth is that it is good eatin’! Be sure to come back next week when I give a little face time to a North Carolina-Style Pulled Pork Sandwich! In the meantime, tell me about your best barbecue experience in the comments!