Al Dente Taste Test: Colas
Colas have come a long way from their humble drug store elixir beginnings. Now at the forefront of the multi-billion dollar beverage industry, colas incite passionate debate over taste, ingredients, marketing, and health.
The Guidelines
This was a blind test with six tasters and six colas. The colas had to contain non-artificial sweeteners (no "diet") and be widely available. We ranked the colas in accordance with the Wine Enthusiast 100-point scale:
<80: Unacceptable
80 – 83: Acceptable
83 – 87: Good
87 – 90: Very Good
90 – 94: Excellent
94 – 98: Superb
98 – 100: Classic
The Contestants
Brand: RC Cola
Company: Cadbury Schweppes
Claims to fame: great with moon-pies
Sweetener: high-fructose corn syrup
Taste: "tasted flat and sugary, like someone had let it sit out"; "plastic, synthetic aftertaste"
Ranking: 83
Brand: 365 Cola
Company: Whole Foods
Claims to fame: all natural; contains kola nut extract
Sweetener: cane sugar
Taste: "was very sweet but not in a fake sugary way"; "actual cola nut taste"; "tasted real"
Ranking: 85
Brand: Coca-Cola Classic
Company: Coca-Cola Company
Claims to fame: being "it" and "the real thing"
Sweetener: high-fructose corn syrup
Taste: "bland"; "very familiar taste"; "bubbly and sweet"
Ranking: 87
Brand: Pepsi
Company: PepsiCo
Claims to fame: choice of a new generation; winner of the 70's "Pepsi Challenge"
Sweetener: high-fructose corn syrup
Taste: "too sweet"; "horrible"; "some chemical aftertaste"
Ranking: 81
Brand: Mexican Coca-Cola
Company: Coca-Cola Company
Claims to fame: no HFCS; can be found at Costco
Sweetener: cane sugar
Taste: "surprisingly fruity"; "tastes like real sugar instead of chemical crap"
Ranking: 88
Brand: Big K Cola
Company: Kroger Foods
Claims to fame: it's cheap
Sweetener: high-fructose corn syrup
Taste: "really bland"; "passable"; "not much flavor at all"
Ranking: 84
And the Winner is...
While none of the contestants cracked 90, the overall winner was Mexican Coca-Cola, with Coca-Cola Classic coming in a very close second. Sadly, Mexican Coca-Cola is only available a Costco. We all hope that corn prices will outpace sugar prices so that more "real sugar" sodas will come to market. I'm looking at you Dr. Pepper--quit hiding the good stuff in Texas.
--Spanno
CB on June 23, 2008 at 10:48 AM
I have always been a coca cola drinker. During the infamous "new Coke" mess in the 80's I switched to RC or Dr. Pepper. Recently I came upon Mexican Coca-Cola at my local 'Cash & Carry' market - where local small restaurants go to pick up supplies daily. I find that not only does it taste better - like the refreshing soft drink of my youth - I only want one. No thirst when I'm done, if I can even finish the bottle. - CB
Spanno on June 23, 2008 at 10:52 AM
I had that same issue! I couldn't finish an entire bottle.
Flap Jackson on June 23, 2008 at 12:37 PM
Pepsi is awesome, Coke is terrible. Haven't had the other ones.
absolute zero on June 23, 2008 at 01:22 PM
I avoid regular sodas...will you be doing a diet tasting as well?
Spanno on June 23, 2008 at 01:28 PM
Doubtful. We're very anti-diet around here.
Chris on June 23, 2008 at 02:10 PM
Check the ethnic food aisle at your local supermarket for the Mexican Coca-Cola--my local Kroger's (Ohio) has it. I'm told that if you have a good kosher market nearby, kosher Coke is similar, if not identical to the Mexican stuff. . .
kevin on June 24, 2008 at 12:28 PM
As far as I know, "kosher Coke" is only available at Passover -- there are stricter rules for some Jews during Passover, one of which is avoiding corn, hence the no-corn-syrup Coke. (disclaimer, IANAJ.) I tried it for the first time this past spring, and both my and my wife's reactions were "This tastes like European Coke". Which was a good thing in our opinion. Hadn't thought of looking for Mexican Coke, I'll keep an eye out.
Different kevin on June 26, 2008 at 07:31 PM
You can ID the über-kosher Coke by a yellow cap. Here in San Diego it's only available in 2 L bottles - and they will eventually go flat/bad because the plastic is somewhat porous, so don't try to stock up a years worth of them
roux on July 02, 2008 at 02:18 PM
Mexican coca cola? Wow, sounds great. My father-in-law saved the old coke cans, "new coke" cans and classic coke cans. The difference is corn syrup vs cane sugar.
I always knew the "new coke" scam was to allow corn syrup in the mix.
roux on July 02, 2008 at 02:18 PM
Mexican coca cola? Wow, sounds great. My father-in-law saved the old coke cans, "new coke" cans and classic coke cans. The difference is corn syrup vs cane sugar.
I always knew the "new coke" scam was to allow corn syrup in the mix.
Peter Clifford on December 02, 2010 at 06:09 PM
I REMEMBER WHEN COKE HAD "REAL" TASTE IT WAS FIFTEEN YEARS AGO AUSTRALIAN COKE HAS A TINY AMOUNT OF CANE SUGAR IN IT BUT THEY ONLY PUT ONE TENTH IN IT SO IF I DRINK IT COLD IT'S TOO FIZZY SO I DRINK IT WARM AND IT'S SORT OF SWEET BUT HAS A WOEFULLY ACIDIC/PLASTIC/DIRT/BURNT AFTERTASTE WHICH IS DISGUSTING EVER OPEN A BOTTLE OF COKE HAD A SIP AND ALL YOU COULD TASTE IS THE TASTE OF "CORN" THATS WHAT COKE HERE TASTES LIKE!
WISH I HAD SOME MEXI-COKE I MISS THAT SWEET 'N SHINY TASTE COULD DRINK A GALLON OF IT!
CABAL RMT on February 12, 2011 at 12:24 AM
rmt
The Maritime Union, ARGO聽RMT
have been speaking to 3FM following yesterday's銉囥偒銉兂聽RMT
shock announcement 銈€儵銉壜爎mt
that Mezeron were to aion聽rmt
cease their Liverpool freight services.Hellgate聽RMT
General Secretary Bob Crow has brandedff14聽rmt
the news a major victory for the Steam Packet workers,鐪熉犱笁鍦嬬劇鍙宱nline聽RMT
who up until this point had been fearingdragon聽nest聽rmt
for their jobs and the future of the company.Since the launch of Mezeron's competitive freight service they had taken some significant customers away from the Steak Packet,鐪犮倝銇亜澶ч櫢銈儹銉庛偣聽RMT
including Shoprite銉°偆銉椼儷銈广儓銉笺儶銉悸燫MT
and Tesco,銈€儓銉┿兂銉嗐偅銈燫MT
it's believed that now淇￠暦銇噹鏈汷nline聽RMT
they have ceased over local 300 jobs have been safeguarded.銉儘銉笺偢銉�rmt
Mezeron said ultimately it was a very ambitious project,銈ㄣ偪銉笺儕銉偒銈偣聽RMT
one which didn't see the volume growth expected and neccessary for them to 銉夈儵銈淬兂銉嶃偣銉埪爎mt
continue operating.銉兗銈汇兂銉堛儚銉笺儓聽RMT
have said that the threat 銈€儵銉夋垿瑷樎爎mt
of more competition isn't completely gone however,DEKARON聽RMT
and say they remain vigilant and geared up澶ц埅娴锋檪浠Ｂ燫MT
if any other threats are posed toCABAL聽RMT
the future of the Steam Packet service.CRONOUS聽RMT